So, what WERE Shelob/Ungoliant anyhow? | Page 2 | The Tolkien …
WEBAug 16, 2003 · Well, Sauron was once a Maia. What about Ungoliant? Did she ever serve any of the Valar? I don't think so. Therefore, it seems she is not a Maia, and never was a Maia, according to the quote offered by Manveru, that talks about "the Maiar, the people of the Valar, and their servants and...
Paths of the Dead: Stripped of its fear? | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
WEBApr 21, 2004 · I'm just mad that when Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli walk into the path of the dead, and all we see is were the king is.
who do you think is the true hero of lotr? | Page 37 | The Tolkien ...
WEBAug 23, 2022 · I quite agree with you Gil-Galad. It does feel like we are talking to children who refuse to listen to reason
Arwen's death | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
WEBJan 13, 2004 · I always took it that, with Aragorn's death, a new age had been ushered in. Arwen was part of the old age, the past, and would have felt out of place within the new age. Also, she knew she would die soon. She bids farewell to her daughters it is said. I'm pretty sure she made it clear that she...
LOTR Would Have Been Better Without The evil sam! Obviously!
WEBMar 11, 2003 · What is up, dudes? Having all kinds of fun? Oh, I hope so! Why not? Anyways, I was talking about this in some little debating bar we have in the...
The nomad is curious | The Tolkien Forum
WEBNov 23, 2003 · After watching the TTT:EE and the writers' commentary some things seem clearer to me now as why the writers would even write such things. 1. All of Rohan at Helm's Deep, the Elves showing up It is the writers' contention that every battle should have a purpose. And that a battle that has...
Creatures of the 'Dark Lands'? | The Tolkien Forum
WEBMar 11, 2002 · Does anybody know what kind of creatures inhabit the 'Dark Lands' of Arda?
My own theory on what Tom Bombadil and Goldberry are
WEBJul 13, 2019 · Yes, it's in the poem "The Adventures of Tom Bombadil"; she's the "River-woman's daughter", who pulls him into the water. He escapes, but returns and captures her. That cover you show is interesting, S-eS. "Edited by Christina Scull & Wayne G. Hammond", "Illustrated by Pauline Baynes". Baynes...
Why did the Watcher go for Frodo? | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
WEBAug 19, 2002 · Watcher in the Water What was the Watcher in the swollen waters of the Sirannon outside the west entrance into Moria?
what are you most excited to see in ROTK? | The Tolkien Forum
WEBMar 3, 2003 · the thing i'm most excited to see is Eowyn whipping off her disguise and revealing herself! nobody (except for book fans) will be expecing it!!!! that was...