Shop Vintage Muppet Toys

Ads
$105.99
Puppet Show Muppets Theater Building Blocks Set Compatible Figures Character Stage Bricks Toys For Children Gifts
Walmart
Free shipping
$105.99
Puppet Show Muppets Theater Building Blocks Set Compatible Figures Character Stage Bricks Toys For Children Gifts
Walmart
Free shipping
$18.99
GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11"
Amazon.com
6K+
Price dropped 22% below its 90-day average
$18.99
GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11"
Amazon.com
6K+
$26.45
GUND Sesame Street Official The Count Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Black/Green, 14"
Amazon.com
21K+
Great Color · High-quality Material · Perfect for Gifting · Well-crafted · polyester
$26.45
GUND Sesame Street Official The Count Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Black/Green, 14"
Amazon.com
21K+
$10.00
Funko Disney The Muppets Pop Kermit & Constantine Vinyl Figure Set Hot Topic Exclusive
Hot Topic
Price dropped 58% below its 90-day average
$10.00
Funko Disney The Muppets Pop Kermit & Constantine Vinyl Figure Set Hot Topic Exclusive
Hot Topic
58 % price drop
$81.00
$90.00
Stuffed Animal Jim Henson's The Muppet Show Plush Toys 24" Soft Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Childrens Toy Kids Toy
Etsy
Used
10% off
$81.00
$90.00
Stuffed Animal Jim Henson's The Muppet Show Plush Toys 24" Soft Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Childrens Toy Kids Toy
Etsy
Used
$110.00
Muppet Labs Playset W/ Beaker Action Figure Rare Vintage/ Mint
eBay
$110.00
Muppet Labs Playset W/ Beaker Action Figure Rare Vintage/ Mint
eBay
$44.99
Lego Minifigures The Muppets 71035 Limited Edition (Pack Of 6)
Walmart
67
Free shipping
90-day returns
$44.99
Lego Minifigures The Muppets 71035 Limited Edition (Pack Of 6)
Walmart
67
$49.99
The Muppets Series 6 Beaker Action Figure [Vanishing Cream, Baggie]
Walmart
30-day returns
$49.99
The Muppets Series 6 Beaker Action Figure [Vanishing Cream, Baggie]
Walmart
30-day returns
$29.99
Vintage Jim Henson The Muppets Character Toys
Etsy
Free shipping
Used
$29.99
Vintage Jim Henson The Muppets Character Toys
Etsy
Free shipping
$20.00
Vintage Muppets Collection
Etsy
Used
$20.00
Vintage Muppets Collection
Etsy
Used
$48.27
Muppets Kermit Plush Stuffed Animal Doll 850 Fisher Price Vintage
Etsy
Used
$48.27
Muppets Kermit Plush Stuffed Animal Doll 850 Fisher Price Vintage
Etsy
Used
$164.94
Complete Set Of 8 Rare Muppets Hand Puppets - Exclusive Albert Heijn & Jim Henson Release
Etsy
Free shipping
Price dropped 19% below its 90-day average
$164.94
Complete Set Of 8 Rare Muppets Hand Puppets - Exclusive Albert Heijn & Jim Henson Release
Etsy
19 % price drop
$499.95
Ultra Rare Vintage 1978 Animal Muppets 18" Hand Puppet Fisher Price
eBay
Free shipping
$499.95
Ultra Rare Vintage 1978 Animal Muppets 18" Hand Puppet Fisher Price
eBay
Free shipping
$46.00
Muppets Pog Complete Collection With Slammers Jim Henson 1995 Kermit The Frog Miss Piggy
Etsy
6K+
Free shipping
Used
$46.00
Muppets Pog Complete Collection With Slammers Jim Henson 1995 Kermit The Frog Miss Piggy
Etsy
6K+
$13.50
$18.00
Miss Piggy And Kermit The Frog Christmas Plushies, Cute 1980S Miss Piggy And Kermit, Jim Henson Muppets, Miss Piggy, Kermit Doll
Etsy
Used
25% off
$13.50
$18.00
Miss Piggy And Kermit The Frog Christmas Plushies, Cute 1980S Miss Piggy And Kermit, Jim Henson Muppets, Miss Piggy, Kermit Doll
Etsy
Used
$29.99
$49.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Strawberry Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
40% off
$29.99
$49.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Strawberry Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
$21.58
$25.39
Vintage 80S Sesame Street Figurines Muppets Lot Of 6 Toys
Etsy
Used
15% off
$21.58
$25.39
Vintage 80S Sesame Street Figurines Muppets Lot Of 6 Toys
Etsy
Used
$11.05
The Muppet Show, The Muppets, Big Bird, Muppet Character, Jim Henson, Sesame Street, The Puppet, Vintage Tyco Playtime 1993, TV Series
Etsy
$11.05
The Muppet Show, The Muppets, Big Bird, Muppet Character, Jim Henson, Sesame Street, The Puppet, Vintage Tyco Playtime 1993, TV Series
Etsy
$39.99
$69.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - M, Strawberry Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
42% off
$39.99
$69.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - M, Strawberry Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
$194.95
1982 Fisher Price The Great Gonzo Dress-Up Muppet Doll, In Original Box- Vintage Gonzo Muppet Show Doll
Etsy
Free shipping
Used
$194.95
1982 Fisher Price The Great Gonzo Dress-Up Muppet Doll, In Original Box- Vintage Gonzo Muppet Show Doll
Etsy
Free shipping
$13.20
The Muppets 25th Anniversary Happy Meal Toys, Sealed! CHOOSE YOUR OWN, 2002 Muppets Plush Mcdonalds Kermit, Miss Piggy, Animal Etc
Etsy
1K+
Used
$13.20
The Muppets 25th Anniversary Happy Meal Toys, Sealed! CHOOSE YOUR OWN, 2002 Muppets Plush Mcdonalds Kermit, Miss Piggy, Animal Etc
Etsy
1K+
$119.98
Vintage Fisher-Price Toys Kermit The Frog Jim Henson Muppet Puppet 10"
eBay
Free shipping
Used
$119.98
Vintage Fisher-Price Toys Kermit The Frog Jim Henson Muppet Puppet 10"
eBay
Free shipping
$29.99
$49.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Carrot Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
40% off
$29.99
$49.99
Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Carrot Bunny
modernonlinemart.com
$29.06
$36.33
Vintage Fraggle Rock Muppet Toy Figures Vegetable Cars Set Of 4 Mcdonalds '80S
Etsy
Used
20% off
$29.06
$36.33
Vintage Fraggle Rock Muppet Toy Figures Vegetable Cars Set Of 4 Mcdonalds '80S
Etsy
Used
$14.39
Squishmallows The Muppets Miss Piggy 8 Inch Plush
BoxLunch
Price dropped 27% below its 90-day average
$14.39
Squishmallows The Muppets Miss Piggy 8 Inch Plush
BoxLunch
27 % price drop
$175.00
Vintage Jim Henson Muppets Animal Puppet Doll Fisher Price 854 Quaker
eBay
Free shipping
Used
$175.00
Vintage Jim Henson Muppets Animal Puppet Doll Fisher Price 854 Quaker
eBay
Free shipping
$36.44
Miss Piggy Beanbag Doll Fisher Price 867 Muppets Rooted Hair Rubber Face 7 Inch
Etsy
Used
$36.44
Miss Piggy Beanbag Doll Fisher Price 867 Muppets Rooted Hair Rubber Face 7 Inch
Etsy
Used
$56.00
The Muppets Show Swedish Chef Action Figure Playset With Chicken, Kitchen Diorama Table, Pots, Pans, Display Props, Classic Muppets Toys
Etsy
Free shipping
Used
$56.00
The Muppets Show Swedish Chef Action Figure Playset With Chicken, Kitchen Diorama Table, Pots, Pans, Display Props, Classic Muppets Toys
Etsy
Free shipping
$149.99
RARE - Vintage Muppet Babies Drum - 1985 - Jim Henson Associates, Inc.
Etsy
Free shipping
Used
$149.99
RARE - Vintage Muppet Babies Drum - 1985 - Jim Henson Associates, Inc.
Etsy
Free shipping
$12.90
Muppet Babies Playroom Set 2.5" Figures Lot Of 5 Vintage
Etsy
Used
$12.90
Muppet Babies Playroom Set 2.5" Figures Lot Of 5 Vintage
Etsy
Used
$54.00
Vintage 1980'S Gonzo Muppet Plush | Retro Fisher-Price Gonzo Plush Jim Henson Muppet Show | Retro Gonzo Stuffed Animal Muppet
Etsy
1K+
Free shipping
Used
$54.00
Vintage 1980'S Gonzo Muppet Plush | Retro Fisher-Price Gonzo Plush Jim Henson Muppet Show | Retro Gonzo Stuffed Animal Muppet
Etsy
1K+
$22.50
$25.00
Stuffed Sesame Street Gaspar Plush Toys 12" Stuffed Doll Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Plush Childrens Kids Toy
Etsy
Used
10% off
$22.50
$25.00
Stuffed Sesame Street Gaspar Plush Toys 12" Stuffed Doll Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Plush Childrens Kids Toy
Etsy
Used
$38.69
Vintage Gonzo Plush Junior Toys AG | The Muppets | Muppet Show | Gonzo Hug
Etsy
Used
$38.69
Vintage Gonzo Plush Junior Toys AG | The Muppets | Muppet Show | Gonzo Hug
Etsy
Used
$33.75
$45.00
Vintage 1980S 80S 1983 Hasbro Softies Muppet Babies Kermit The Frog Doll Toy Plush
Etsy
Used
25% off
$33.75
$45.00
Vintage 1980S 80S 1983 Hasbro Softies Muppet Babies Kermit The Frog Doll Toy Plush
Etsy
Used
$48.75
Vintage 1978 Fozzie Bear Muppet Fisher Price Jim Henson 861 Hand Puppet
Etsy
Price dropped 21% below its 90-day average
$48.75
Vintage 1978 Fozzie Bear Muppet Fisher Price Jim Henson 861 Hand Puppet
Etsy
21 % price drop
$5.89
Vintage Muppet Show
AliExpress
Free shipping
Price dropped 20% below its 90-day average
$5.89
Vintage Muppet Show
AliExpress
20 % price drop
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Vintage Muppet Toys

    Ads
    $105.99
    Puppet Show Muppets Theater Building Blocks Set Compatible Figures Character Stage Bricks Toys For Children Gifts
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $105.99
    Puppet Show Muppets Theater Building Blocks Set Compatible Figures Character Stage Bricks Toys For Children Gifts
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $18.99
    GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11"
    Amazon.com
    6K+
    Price dropped 22% below its 90-day average
    $18.99
    GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11"
    Amazon.com
    6K+
    $26.45
    GUND Sesame Street Official The Count Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Black/Green, 14"
    Amazon.com
    21K+
    Great Color · High-quality Material · Perfect for Gifting · Well-crafted · polyester
    $26.45
    GUND Sesame Street Official The Count Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy For Ages 1 & Up, Black/Green, 14"
    Amazon.com
    21K+
    $10.00
    Funko Disney The Muppets Pop Kermit & Constantine Vinyl Figure Set Hot Topic Exclusive
    Hot Topic
    Price dropped 58% below its 90-day average
    $10.00
    Funko Disney The Muppets Pop Kermit & Constantine Vinyl Figure Set Hot Topic Exclusive
    Hot Topic
    58 % price drop
    $81.00
    $90.00
    Stuffed Animal Jim Henson's The Muppet Show Plush Toys 24" Soft Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Childrens Toy Kids Toy
    Etsy
    Used
    10% off
    $81.00
    $90.00
    Stuffed Animal Jim Henson's The Muppet Show Plush Toys 24" Soft Toys Vintage The Muppets Collectible Toy Childrens Toy Kids Toy
    Etsy
    Used
    $110.00
    Muppet Labs Playset W/ Beaker Action Figure Rare Vintage/ Mint
    eBay
    $110.00
    Muppet Labs Playset W/ Beaker Action Figure Rare Vintage/ Mint
    eBay
    $44.99
    Lego Minifigures The Muppets 71035 Limited Edition (Pack Of 6)
    Walmart
    67
    Free shipping
    90-day returns
    $44.99
    Lego Minifigures The Muppets 71035 Limited Edition (Pack Of 6)
    Walmart
    67
    $49.99
    The Muppets Series 6 Beaker Action Figure [Vanishing Cream, Baggie]
    Walmart
    30-day returns
    $49.99
    The Muppets Series 6 Beaker Action Figure [Vanishing Cream, Baggie]
    Walmart
    30-day returns
    $29.99
    Vintage Jim Henson The Muppets Character Toys
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    Used
    $29.99
    Vintage Jim Henson The Muppets Character Toys
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $20.00
    Vintage Muppets Collection
    Etsy
    Used
    $20.00
    Vintage Muppets Collection
    Etsy
    Used
    $48.27
    Muppets Kermit Plush Stuffed Animal Doll 850 Fisher Price Vintage
    Etsy
    Used
    $48.27
    Muppets Kermit Plush Stuffed Animal Doll 850 Fisher Price Vintage
    Etsy
    Used
    $164.94
    Complete Set Of 8 Rare Muppets Hand Puppets - Exclusive Albert Heijn & Jim Henson Release
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    Price dropped 19% below its 90-day average
    $164.94
    Complete Set Of 8 Rare Muppets Hand Puppets - Exclusive Albert Heijn & Jim Henson Release
    Etsy
    19 % price drop
    $499.95
    Ultra Rare Vintage 1978 Animal Muppets 18" Hand Puppet Fisher Price
    eBay
    Free shipping
    $499.95
    Ultra Rare Vintage 1978 Animal Muppets 18" Hand Puppet Fisher Price
    eBay
    Free shipping
    $46.00
    Muppets Pog Complete Collection With Slammers Jim Henson 1995 Kermit The Frog Miss Piggy
    Etsy
    6K+
    Free shipping
    Used
    $46.00
    Muppets Pog Complete Collection With Slammers Jim Henson 1995 Kermit The Frog Miss Piggy
    Etsy
    6K+
    $13.50
    $18.00
    Miss Piggy And Kermit The Frog Christmas Plushies, Cute 1980S Miss Piggy And Kermit, Jim Henson Muppets, Miss Piggy, Kermit Doll
    Etsy
    Used
    25% off
    $13.50
    $18.00
    Miss Piggy And Kermit The Frog Christmas Plushies, Cute 1980S Miss Piggy And Kermit, Jim Henson Muppets, Miss Piggy, Kermit Doll
    Etsy
    Used
    $29.99
    $49.99
    Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Strawberry Bunny
    modernonlinemart.com
    40% off
    $29.99
    $49.99
    Rabbit Muppet Toys - S, Strawberry Bunny
    modernonlinemart.com
    $21.58
    $25.39
    Vintage 80S Sesame Street Figurines Muppets Lot Of 6 Toys
    Etsy
    Used
    15% off
    $21.58
    $25.39
    Vintage 80S Sesame Street Figurines Muppets Lot Of 6 Toys
    Etsy
    Used
    $11.05
    The Muppet Show, The Muppets, Big Bird, Muppet Character, Jim Henson, Sesame Street, The Puppet, Vintage Tyco Playtime 1993, TV Series
    Etsy
    $11.05
    The Muppet Show, The Muppets, Big Bird, Muppet Character, Jim Henson, Sesame Street, The Puppet, Vintage Tyco Playtime 1993, TV Series
    Etsy

    • Vintage Muppet Toys On eBay | Seriously, We Have Everything