Shop Amish Mennonite Christmas Gifts

Sponsored
$25.99
$34.95
Williams Sonoma Winter Berry Guest Set
Williams Sonoma
In store
25% off
$25.99
$34.95
Williams Sonoma Winter Berry Guest Set
Williams Sonoma
$2.99
Ladyfinger Hulless Popcorn | Size: 14Oz Bottle | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$2.99
Ladyfinger Hulless Popcorn | Size: 14Oz Bottle | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$29.99
$39.99
Collections Etc Amish Wagon Decorative Indoor/Outdoor Garden Backyard Planter, Green
Collections Etc.
2K+
25% off
$29.99
$39.99
Collections Etc Amish Wagon Decorative Indoor/Outdoor Garden Backyard Planter, Green
Collections Etc.
2K+
$29.99
Microwave Popcorn Gift Bowl Set | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$29.99
Microwave Popcorn Gift Bowl Set | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$114.50
Christmas Gifts | Christmas Gift | Christmas Gift Box | Our Christmas Gifts Filled With Amish Baked Goods And Gourmet Foods For The Holidays
Etsy
89
$114.50
Christmas Gifts | Christmas Gift | Christmas Gift Box | Our Christmas Gifts Filled With Amish Baked Goods And Gourmet Foods For The Holidays
Etsy
89
$84.98
Amish Gift Basket - Assorted Items
Etsy
427
Free shipping
$84.98
Amish Gift Basket - Assorted Items
Etsy
427
$16.99
Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church | Indoor/Outdoor | 14" Tall
Walmart
$16.99
Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church | Indoor/Outdoor | 14" Tall
Walmart
$6.95
Williams Sonoma Honey Dipper, Walnut
Williams Sonoma
$6.95
Williams Sonoma Honey Dipper, Walnut
Williams Sonoma
$89.00
Amish Country Tour And Traditional Meal
Virgin Experience Gifts
$89.00
Amish Country Tour And Traditional Meal
Virgin Experience Gifts
$19.42
$25.90
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Hat, Presidential Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
3K+
25% off
$19.42
$25.90
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Hat, Presidential Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
3K+
$165.00
Large Wind Chime | Listen To The Wind | Memorial Gift | Amish Wind Chime | Made In USA | Sympathy | Loss Of Loved One
Etsy
9K+
Free shipping
$165.00
Large Wind Chime | Listen To The Wind | Memorial Gift | Amish Wind Chime | Made In USA | Sympathy | Loss Of Loved One
Etsy
9K+
$44.95
Oaksip The Original Wooden Bourbon Drinking Glass Bourbon Gifts For Men | Finished Wooden Old Fashioned Glass | Great Whiskey Gifts For Men, Dad, Or
Amazon.com
619
Free shipping
$44.95
Oaksip The Original Wooden Bourbon Drinking Glass Bourbon Gifts For Men | Finished Wooden Old Fashioned Glass | Great Whiskey Gifts For Men, Dad, Or
Amazon.com
619
$42.99
Whirley Pop Variety Set | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$42.99
Whirley Pop Variety Set | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
$80.00
Amish Gift Basket 3
Etsy
1
$80.00
Amish Gift Basket 3
Etsy
1
$12.99
Amish Handmade Apron White Tie Apron Plain Mennonite
Etsy
762
$12.99
Amish Handmade Apron White Tie Apron Plain Mennonite
Etsy
762
$39.99
SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
Amazon.com
13K+
Free shipping
$39.99
SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
Amazon.com
13K+
$19.80
$22.00
Customizable Amish Christmas Ornament, Amish Country Gift Souvenir, Christmas Gift, Amish Horse And Buggy, Amish Family Gift, Ceramic
Etsy
1K+
Free shipping
10% off
$19.80
$22.00
Customizable Amish Christmas Ornament, Amish Country Gift Souvenir, Christmas Gift, Amish Horse And Buggy, Amish Family Gift, Ceramic
Etsy
1K+
$34.48
$45.98
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Hoodie, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
Free shipping
25% off
$34.48
$45.98
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Hoodie, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
Free shipping
$9.99
Up To 6 Seasonings | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
Free shipping
$9.99
Up To 6 Seasonings | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
Free shipping
$15.99
2 - 2 Lb. Bags And 1 - 1 Lb. Bag Of Popcorn | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
Free shipping
$15.99
2 - 2 Lb. Bags And 1 - 1 Lb. Bag Of Popcorn | Amish Country Popcorn
Amish Country Popcorn
Free shipping
$78.00
Mid Century Amish Mennonite Pilgram Man And Woman Male Female Couple Pair Set Of Two 2 Ceramic Figurine 18 Inches Hand Painted Signed 1967
Etsy
$78.00
Mid Century Amish Mennonite Pilgram Man And Woman Male Female Couple Pair Set Of Two 2 Ceramic Figurine 18 Inches Hand Painted Signed 1967
Etsy
$10.99
Signmission 7 X 10 in. Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign - Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church
Walmart
$10.99
Signmission 7 X 10 in. Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign - Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church
Walmart
$17.62
$23.50
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Tee Shirt, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
Free shipping
25% off
$17.62
$23.50
Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Tee Shirt, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
Etsy
Free shipping
$29.99
$59.98
Leather Fly Swatter Amish Flyswatter Gift For Men Handmade Housewarming Gift Household Item Groomsmen Gift - Lifetime Leather
Etsy
13K+
50% off
$29.99
$59.98
Leather Fly Swatter Amish Flyswatter Gift For Men Handmade Housewarming Gift Household Item Groomsmen Gift - Lifetime Leather
Etsy
13K+
$38.99
$59.99
Personalized Vintage Needlepoint Stocking Collection - Personal Creations Customized Stockings Christmas Home Décor Gifts
Personal Creations
35% off
$38.99
$59.99
Personalized Vintage Needlepoint Stocking Collection - Personal Creations Customized Stockings Christmas Home Décor Gifts
Personal Creations
$12.99
An Amish Family Christmas (Ebook)
VitalSource
2
Free shipping
$12.99
An Amish Family Christmas (Ebook)
VitalSource
2
$24.00
Amish Mennonite Small Women's Long Cape Dress B34 Modest Handmade Sage Green
Etsy
$24.00
Amish Mennonite Small Women's Long Cape Dress B34 Modest Handmade Sage Green
Etsy
$59.99
SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
Amazon.com
19K+
Free shipping
$59.99
SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
Amazon.com
19K+
$30.00
Primitive Bonnet. Prairie, Amish, Mennonite.
Etsy
Free shipping
$30.00
Primitive Bonnet. Prairie, Amish, Mennonite.
Etsy
Free shipping
$172.50
Holiday Gift Basket | Holiday Gift Ideas | Unique Christmas Gift | Amish Whole Horse And Buggy With Traditional Holiday Favorites.
Etsy
116
Free shipping
$172.50
Holiday Gift Basket | Holiday Gift Ideas | Unique Christmas Gift | Amish Whole Horse And Buggy With Traditional Holiday Favorites.
Etsy
116
$14.95
Keychain Husband Christmas Gift Hunting Gifts For Men Gifts For Men Deer Gifts Hunting Gifts Amish Handcrafted Leather Keychain
Etsy
983
$14.95
Keychain Husband Christmas Gift Hunting Gifts For Men Gifts For Men Deer Gifts Hunting Gifts Amish Handcrafted Leather Keychain
Etsy
983
$44.00
Amish/Mennonite Cross Stitch Framed Needlepoint
Etsy
Free shipping
$44.00
Amish/Mennonite Cross Stitch Framed Needlepoint
Etsy
Free shipping
$25.00
Amish Mennonite Women's Medium Cape Dress Bust 38 Modest Handmade Black , White
Etsy
$25.00
Amish Mennonite Women's Medium Cape Dress Bust 38 Modest Handmade Black , White
Etsy
$234.39
$275.75
Antique Carved Wood Miniature Doll Figures, Amish, Mennonite, Folk Art
Etsy
3K+
14% off
$234.39
$275.75
Antique Carved Wood Miniature Doll Figures, Amish, Mennonite, Folk Art
Etsy
3K+
$17.59
$21.99
Pennsylvania, Amish Country Personalizable Ornament, Family Vacation, Road Trip Memento, Travel Gift, Souvenir, Keepsake
Etsy
618
20% off
$17.59
$21.99
Pennsylvania, Amish Country Personalizable Ornament, Family Vacation, Road Trip Memento, Travel Gift, Souvenir, Keepsake
Etsy
618
$37.00
Amish Made Basket For Your Kitchen Counter Or You Can Use It For A Gift Basket. Made In Michigan
Etsy
55
Free shipping
$37.00
Amish Made Basket For Your Kitchen Counter Or You Can Use It For A Gift Basket. Made In Michigan
Etsy
55
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Amish Mennonite Christmas Gifts

    Sponsored
    $25.99
    $34.95
    Williams Sonoma Winter Berry Guest Set
    Williams Sonoma
    In store
    25% off
    $25.99
    $34.95
    Williams Sonoma Winter Berry Guest Set
    Williams Sonoma
    $2.99
    Ladyfinger Hulless Popcorn | Size: 14Oz Bottle | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $2.99
    Ladyfinger Hulless Popcorn | Size: 14Oz Bottle | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $29.99
    $39.99
    Collections Etc Amish Wagon Decorative Indoor/Outdoor Garden Backyard Planter, Green
    Collections Etc.
    2K+
    25% off
    $29.99
    $39.99
    Collections Etc Amish Wagon Decorative Indoor/Outdoor Garden Backyard Planter, Green
    Collections Etc.
    2K+
    $29.99
    Microwave Popcorn Gift Bowl Set | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $29.99
    Microwave Popcorn Gift Bowl Set | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $114.50
    Christmas Gifts | Christmas Gift | Christmas Gift Box | Our Christmas Gifts Filled With Amish Baked Goods And Gourmet Foods For The Holidays
    Etsy
    89
    $114.50
    Christmas Gifts | Christmas Gift | Christmas Gift Box | Our Christmas Gifts Filled With Amish Baked Goods And Gourmet Foods For The Holidays
    Etsy
    89
    $84.98
    Amish Gift Basket - Assorted Items
    Etsy
    427
    Free shipping
    $84.98
    Amish Gift Basket - Assorted Items
    Etsy
    427
    $16.99
    Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church | Indoor/Outdoor | 14" Tall
    Walmart
    $16.99
    Amish Buggy Parking Aluminum Sign Horse Carriage Religious Mennonite Church | Indoor/Outdoor | 14" Tall
    Walmart
    $6.95
    Williams Sonoma Honey Dipper, Walnut
    Williams Sonoma
    $6.95
    Williams Sonoma Honey Dipper, Walnut
    Williams Sonoma
    $89.00
    Amish Country Tour And Traditional Meal
    Virgin Experience Gifts
    $89.00
    Amish Country Tour And Traditional Meal
    Virgin Experience Gifts
    $19.42
    $25.90
    Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Hat, Presidential Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
    Etsy
    3K+
    25% off
    $19.42
    $25.90
    Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Hat, Presidential Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
    Etsy
    3K+
    $165.00
    Large Wind Chime | Listen To The Wind | Memorial Gift | Amish Wind Chime | Made In USA | Sympathy | Loss Of Loved One
    Etsy
    9K+
    Free shipping
    $165.00
    Large Wind Chime | Listen To The Wind | Memorial Gift | Amish Wind Chime | Made In USA | Sympathy | Loss Of Loved One
    Etsy
    9K+
    $44.95
    Oaksip The Original Wooden Bourbon Drinking Glass Bourbon Gifts For Men | Finished Wooden Old Fashioned Glass | Great Whiskey Gifts For Men, Dad, Or
    Amazon.com
    619
    Free shipping
    $44.95
    Oaksip The Original Wooden Bourbon Drinking Glass Bourbon Gifts For Men | Finished Wooden Old Fashioned Glass | Great Whiskey Gifts For Men, Dad, Or
    Amazon.com
    619
    $42.99
    Whirley Pop Variety Set | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $42.99
    Whirley Pop Variety Set | Amish Country Popcorn
    Amish Country Popcorn
    $80.00
    Amish Gift Basket 3
    Etsy
    1
    $80.00
    Amish Gift Basket 3
    Etsy
    1
    $12.99
    Amish Handmade Apron White Tie Apron Plain Mennonite
    Etsy
    762
    $12.99
    Amish Handmade Apron White Tie Apron Plain Mennonite
    Etsy
    762
    $39.99
    SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
    Amazon.com
    13K+
    Free shipping
    $39.99
    SMIRLY Charcuterie Boards Gift Set: Charcuterie Board Set, Bamboo Cheese Board Set - House Warming Gifts New Home, Wedding Gifts For Couple, Bridal
    Amazon.com
    13K+
    $19.80
    $22.00
    Customizable Amish Christmas Ornament, Amish Country Gift Souvenir, Christmas Gift, Amish Horse And Buggy, Amish Family Gift, Ceramic
    Etsy
    1K+
    Free shipping
    10% off
    $19.80
    $22.00
    Customizable Amish Christmas Ornament, Amish Country Gift Souvenir, Christmas Gift, Amish Horse And Buggy, Amish Family Gift, Ceramic
    Etsy
    1K+
    $34.48
    $45.98
    Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Hoodie, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    25% off
    $34.48
    $45.98
    Amish Horse And Buggy Trump Supporter Unisex Hoodie, Election 2024, Amish And Mennonite, Rumspringa, Lancaster County, Republican
    Etsy
    Free shipping