Shop Nativity Scene Replacement Pieces

Sponsored
$100.97
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Holy Family 4 3/8"
Etsy
6K+
$100.97
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Holy Family 4 3/8"
Etsy
6K+
$49.99
Star Of Bethlehem Illuminated Nativity Accessory Featuring A Fully Adjustable Top To Add Light To Nativity By Hawthorne Village
Bradford Exchange
$49.99
Star Of Bethlehem Illuminated Nativity Accessory Featuring A Fully Adjustable Top To Add Light To Nativity By Hawthorne Village
Bradford Exchange
$55.00
Kirkland Signature Nativity Porcelain Replacement Animal Figures Christmas (3)
Etsy
$55.00
Kirkland Signature Nativity Porcelain Replacement Animal Figures Christmas (3)
Etsy
$22.50
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 1 1/4"
Etsy
6K+
$22.50
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 1 1/4"
Etsy
6K+
$68.04
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Resin
Etsy
6K+
$68.04
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Resin
Etsy
6K+
$99.95
Roman Fontanini Heirloom Nativity 5" Scale Village Accessory Set -Set Of 15 4" - Boxed
Replacements, Ltd.
$99.95
Roman Fontanini Heirloom Nativity 5" Scale Village Accessory Set -Set Of 15 4" - Boxed
Replacements, Ltd.
$57.43
10-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
Etsy
Free shipping
$57.43
10-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
Etsy
Free shipping
$68.81
12-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
Etsy
Free shipping
$68.81
12-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
Etsy
Free shipping
$57.07
Nativity Set 8 Pcs Nativity Scene Religious Figures Christmas Ornament
Etsy
$57.07
Nativity Set 8 Pcs Nativity Scene Religious Figures Christmas Ornament
Etsy
$8.00
Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
Etsy
4K+
$8.00
Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
Etsy
4K+
$119.99
Christmas Nativity Set With Stable And Light 11 Pieces
Etsy
1K+
Free shipping
$119.99
Christmas Nativity Set With Stable And Light 11 Pieces
Etsy
1K+
$54.21
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature 2 3/8"
Etsy
6K+
$54.21
Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature 2 3/8"
Etsy
6K+
$15.62
Ready To Paint-REPLACEMENT PIECES For Nativity Set
Etsy
$15.62
Ready To Paint-REPLACEMENT PIECES For Nativity Set
Etsy
$50.00
Kirkland Signature Replacement Nativity MARY Figurine Item 1456711 Vintage
Etsy
Free shipping
$50.00
Kirkland Signature Replacement Nativity MARY Figurine Item 1456711 Vintage
Etsy
Free shipping
$22.99
Vintage Nativity Replacement Figures Mary Joseph & Jesus Made In Korea READ
Etsy
$22.99
Vintage Nativity Replacement Figures Mary Joseph & Jesus Made In Korea READ
Etsy
$32.00
Nativity Manger / 3 Sizes / Nativity Scene Accessories Wood Nativity Manger Minimalist Christmas Decor Crib For Nativity Scene Jesus Manger
Etsy
1K+
$32.00
Nativity Manger / 3 Sizes / Nativity Scene Accessories Wood Nativity Manger Minimalist Christmas Decor Crib For Nativity Scene Jesus Manger
Etsy
1K+
$54.32
Nativity Set Holy Family 3 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 8"
Etsy
6K+
$54.32
Nativity Set Holy Family 3 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 8"
Etsy
6K+
$129.99
Large Nativity Add-On Three Kings
Etsy
4K+
Free shipping
$129.99
Large Nativity Add-On Three Kings
Etsy
4K+
$5.00
Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
Etsy
4K+
$5.00
Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
Etsy
4K+
$25.46
Away In A Manger Nativity Stable Metal Shelf Sitter Christmas Decor Nativity Decor Christ In Christmas Handcrafted Holiday Decor
Etsy
$25.46
Away In A Manger Nativity Stable Metal Shelf Sitter Christmas Decor Nativity Decor Christ In Christmas Handcrafted Holiday Decor
Etsy
$17.00
Nativity Figures Extra Or Replacement Pieces Custom Replacements Unpainted Holland Nativity
Etsy
$17.00
Nativity Figures Extra Or Replacement Pieces Custom Replacements Unpainted Holland Nativity
Etsy
$54.00
$60.00
Christmas Nativity Scene Set Figures Polyresin Figurines Baby Jesus-11-PIECE 5"
Etsy
379
Free shipping
10% off
$54.00
$60.00
Christmas Nativity Scene Set Figures Polyresin Figurines Baby Jesus-11-PIECE 5"
Etsy
379
$0.37
$0.53
Unfinished Wooden Nativity Shape | Nativity Scene Wood Cutout Shape | Laser Cut Blanks | Unfinished | DIY Craft Blanks
Etsy
3K+
30% off
$0.37
$0.53
Unfinished Wooden Nativity Shape | Nativity Scene Wood Cutout Shape | Laser Cut Blanks | Unfinished | DIY Craft Blanks
Etsy
3K+
$6.43
Nativity Replacement Figures You Pick- Sold INDIVIDUALLY
Etsy
$6.43
Nativity Replacement Figures You Pick- Sold INDIVIDUALLY
Etsy
$0.34
$0.50
Nativity Scene - Laser Cut Unfinished Wood Cutout Shapes - Always Check Sizes And Measure
Etsy
459
32% off
$0.34
$0.50
Nativity Scene - Laser Cut Unfinished Wood Cutout Shapes - Always Check Sizes And Measure
Etsy
459
$76.50
$90.00
JOSEPH AND MARY Nativity Replacement Porcelain Figures/ Vintage
Etsy
15% off
$76.50
$90.00
JOSEPH AND MARY Nativity Replacement Porcelain Figures/ Vintage
Etsy
$160.00
$200.00
Christmas Felt Nativity Set, 12 Piece Nativity Manger Scene, Ready To Ship
Etsy
6K+
Free shipping
20% off
$160.00
$200.00
Christmas Felt Nativity Set, 12 Piece Nativity Manger Scene, Ready To Ship
Etsy
6K+
$19.99
Wooden Nativity Replacement Pieces, Joseph And Mary, Barn Animals, Boy, Girl, Manger Or Crèche, Stable, Star Of Bethlehem, Assemblage Supply
Etsy
Free shipping
$19.99
Wooden Nativity Replacement Pieces, Joseph And Mary, Barn Animals, Boy, Girl, Manger Or Crèche, Stable, Star Of Bethlehem, Assemblage Supply
Etsy
Free shipping
$59.99
Hawthorne Village Irish Nativity Goats Only 3 1/4" - No Box
Replacements, Ltd.
$59.99
Hawthorne Village Irish Nativity Goats Only 3 1/4" - No Box
Replacements, Ltd.
$22.50
$30.00
Christmas Nativity Metal Home Decor, Nativity Set, Nativity Scene, Manger Scene
Etsy
Free shipping
25% off
$22.50
$30.00
Christmas Nativity Metal Home Decor, Nativity Set, Nativity Scene, Manger Scene
Etsy
Free shipping
$84.99
Nativity Set 8" Nacimiento Navideno 11 Pcs Set
Etsy
159
Free shipping
$84.99
Nativity Set 8" Nacimiento Navideno 11 Pcs Set
Etsy
159
$0.94
$1.38
Nativity Scene - Laser Cut Unfinished Wood Cutout Shapes - Always Check Sizes And Measure
Etsy
29K+
31% off
$0.94
$1.38
Nativity Scene - Laser Cut Unfinished Wood Cutout Shapes - Always Check Sizes And Measure
Etsy
29K+
$38.75
Nativity Ornament Set, Away In A Manger, Hand Painted, Original, Wood
Etsy
170
Free shipping
$38.75
Nativity Ornament Set, Away In A Manger, Hand Painted, Original, Wood
Etsy
170
$10.00
Vintage Choice Of Christmas Nativity Chalkware Plaster Figurine - Replacement Pieces - Some Damage Read Full Description
Etsy
$10.00
Vintage Choice Of Christmas Nativity Chalkware Plaster Figurine - Replacement Pieces - Some Damage Read Full Description
Etsy
$129.99
Colorful Felt Nativity Set - Handmade, Fair Trade Christmas From Nepal
Etsy
986
Free shipping
$129.99
Colorful Felt Nativity Set - Handmade, Fair Trade Christmas From Nepal
Etsy
986
$13.00
Nativity Panel Fabric / 36" Panel By Elizabeth's Studio Religious Panel / Christmas Fabric Panels / Christmas Fabric Panel Quilting Panel
Etsy
41K+
$13.00
Nativity Panel Fabric / 36" Panel By Elizabeth's Studio Religious Panel / Christmas Fabric Panels / Christmas Fabric Panel Quilting Panel
Etsy
41K+
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Nativity Scene Replacement Pieces

    Sponsored
    $100.97
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Holy Family 4 3/8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $100.97
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Holy Family 4 3/8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $49.99
    Star Of Bethlehem Illuminated Nativity Accessory Featuring A Fully Adjustable Top To Add Light To Nativity By Hawthorne Village
    Bradford Exchange
    $49.99
    Star Of Bethlehem Illuminated Nativity Accessory Featuring A Fully Adjustable Top To Add Light To Nativity By Hawthorne Village
    Bradford Exchange
    $55.00
    Kirkland Signature Nativity Porcelain Replacement Animal Figures Christmas (3)
    Etsy
    $55.00
    Kirkland Signature Nativity Porcelain Replacement Animal Figures Christmas (3)
    Etsy
    $22.50
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 1 1/4"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $22.50
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 1 1/4"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $68.04
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Resin
    Etsy
    6K+
    $68.04
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature Resin
    Etsy
    6K+
    $99.95
    Roman Fontanini Heirloom Nativity 5" Scale Village Accessory Set -Set Of 15 4" - Boxed
    Replacements, Ltd.
    $99.95
    Roman Fontanini Heirloom Nativity 5" Scale Village Accessory Set -Set Of 15 4" - Boxed
    Replacements, Ltd.
    $57.43
    10-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $57.43
    10-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $68.81
    12-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $68.81
    12-Piece Nativity Sets For Christmas, Miniature Christmas Nativity. Resin Religious Depicting The Birth Of Baby Jesus For Kids' Christmas.
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $57.07
    Nativity Set 8 Pcs Nativity Scene Religious Figures Christmas Ornament
    Etsy
    $57.07
    Nativity Set 8 Pcs Nativity Scene Religious Figures Christmas Ornament
    Etsy
    $8.00
    Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
    Etsy
    4K+
    $8.00
    Christmas Nativity Replacement Vintage Porcelain Figures
    Etsy
    4K+
    $119.99
    Christmas Nativity Set With Stable And Light 11 Pieces
    Etsy
    1K+
    Free shipping
    $119.99
    Christmas Nativity Set With Stable And Light 11 Pieces
    Etsy
    1K+
    $54.21
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature 2 3/8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $54.21
    Nativity Set 11 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Ornament Miniature 2 3/8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $15.62
    Ready To Paint-REPLACEMENT PIECES For Nativity Set
    Etsy
    $15.62
    Ready To Paint-REPLACEMENT PIECES For Nativity Set
    Etsy
    $50.00
    Kirkland Signature Replacement Nativity MARY Figurine Item 1456711 Vintage
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $50.00
    Kirkland Signature Replacement Nativity MARY Figurine Item 1456711 Vintage
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $22.99
    Vintage Nativity Replacement Figures Mary Joseph & Jesus Made In Korea READ
    Etsy
    $22.99
    Vintage Nativity Replacement Figures Mary Joseph & Jesus Made In Korea READ
    Etsy
    $32.00
    Nativity Manger / 3 Sizes / Nativity Scene Accessories Wood Nativity Manger Minimalist Christmas Decor Crib For Nativity Scene Jesus Manger
    Etsy
    1K+
    $32.00
    Nativity Manger / 3 Sizes / Nativity Scene Accessories Wood Nativity Manger Minimalist Christmas Decor Crib For Nativity Scene Jesus Manger
    Etsy
    1K+
    $54.32
    Nativity Set Holy Family 3 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $54.32
    Nativity Set Holy Family 3 Pcs Religious Figures Christmas Decoration 8"
    Etsy
    6K+
    $129.99
    Large Nativity Add-On Three Kings
    Etsy
    4K+
    Free shipping
    $129.99
    Large Nativity Add-On Three Kings
    Etsy
    4K+